Sirloin vs ribeye: What is the difference? When you walk into your favorite steakhouse, have you ever spent time reading the menu and deliberating which cut of steak to order? If so, chances are you’ve considered ordering either a sirloin or ribeye. Both cuts come from the same part of the cow – the loin area – and share similarities in flavor and texture. But they also contain distinct differences that can make one more appealing than the other depending on personal preference. This blog post will provide an in-depth comparison of these two popular steaks sirloin vs ribeye so that next time you find yourself wavering between sirloin vs ribeye, you’ll be confident in making a decision!
Sirloin Vs Ribeye Comparison
Let’s learn briefly about the similiarities and differences between sirloin vs ribeye!
Similarities Of Sirloin Vs Ribeye:
- Size: Medium to large
- Meat Content: Very meaty
- Fat Content: Moderate levels of fatFlavor
- Profile: Robust and beefy
- Texture: Tender but with a bit of chew
Differences Of Sirloin Vs Ribeye:
- Fat Content: Ribeye contains more fat marbling, making it richer and more flavorful
- Price: Ribeye is generally more expensive due to its higher fat content
- Shape: Sirloin steaks have a uniform shape, while ribeye steaks vary in size and shape
- Cooking Method: Sirloins are best cooked over direct heat, while ribeyes are best cooked over indirect heat
- Average Weight: Sirloin – 6 – 10 oz; Ribeye – 8 – 12 oz.
Sirloin 101
An old wives’ tale claims that King James I of England knighted a piece of beef after devouring it in Scotland. The sensitive cut became known as “Sir loin” from that point forward. Although a good story, it is nearly certainly untrue.
In actuality, the phrase “surloigne,” which means “above the loin,” is the source of the name. Although the word is older than James I’s reign, it is no less historical or interesting. Every steakhouse in the world serves sirloin steaks because they are so widely consumed. Actually, a sirloin of some kind is available at the majority of sit-down restaurants in North America. It and filet mignon are two of the steaks that are most well-known by name.
Unbelievably, there are various sirloin steak varieties. The terms “top sirloin” and “sirloin steak” are most frequently used. In actuality, the NY strip is a specific cut of boneless top sirloin, as was covered in our post on what is NY strip steak. The top sirloin is more tender than the regular or “bottom” sirloin because it is derived from a region of the loin near the tenderloin. However, sirloin steaks in general are fairly tender.
While not a cheap steak, sirloin delivers excellent value for your money when it comes to beef.
Where On The Cow Does Sirloin Come From?
The sirloin primal is situated directly in front of the round, the hindmost primal, near the back of the cow. Top sirloin or bottom sirloin subprimals are used to make sirloin steaks.
Think of a boneless steak in your mind’s eye. Got it? That is most likely how a sirloin appears; it is a traditional, elongated oval (or rounded rectangle) muscle cut that is typically 1 to 1.5 inches thick. This area is also where porterhouse and T-bone steaks are produced.
How Much Meat And Fat Does Sirloin Contain?
Almost all of the meat in a sirloin is trim. One of the leanest beef cuts available, sirloin often has very little to no fat marbling.
A middle cut sirloin steak may have one-third less fat than a top sirloin steak, although this will greatly depend on the cut.
Nutritional Information (Top Sirloin)
- Calories: 156
- Protein: 22.6g
- Total fat: 6.3g
- Saturated fat: 2.4g
- Monounsaturated fat: 2.7g
- Polyunsaturated fat: 0.8g
- Carbohydrates: 0g
- Cholesterol: 59mg
Portion Size: How Much Sirloin Per Person?
An 8 oz dish should be a tolerable meal for most folks because sirloin doesn’t taste as naturally rich as ribeye (because it’s lower in fat). If you really enjoy beef, there are many options available in 10–12 ounce slices.
How To Prepare Sirloin For Grilling Or Smoking
Anyone else interested in hearing the sirloin sizzle? Not yet, we need to get that bad boy ready for the BBQ.
A sirloin has relatively little fat, so trimming shouldn’t be necessary, especially if your butcher did a good job. Although the steak is sensitive, marinating a sirloin is possible, especially a bottom cut. However, don’t wait too long; an hour or two is sufficient; overnight is overkill.
In actuality, you might only want to sprinkle it with salt and pepper (kosher salt is preferred) and sometimes some garlic. Having said that, it’s enjoyable to experiment with flavors, especially given that this is a cost-effective cut, so you won’t worry as much about “ruining”. Compared to, example, a filet mignon, a sirloin. Depending on thickness, leave the sirloin to rest on the counter for 30 to 60 minutes to remove the frost from the refrigerator.
How To Cook Sirloin
Griddle time! And that’s precisely where your sirloin belongs—over the flame on a hot grill. Set one side of your burners to medium-high and the other to low. For those of you who barbecue with charcoal, arrange the coals so that there are two zones.
- Flip the sirloin after about 3 minutes over direct fire to finish searing the opposite side. After three more minutes, you can move to the area with indirect heat.
- The searing time is likely sufficient for thinner portions cooked to medium-rare, but check with your digital meat thermometer to be sure.
- Leave the steak on the indirect side until it’s done if you need longer time or prefer your steak medium or well done.
- Before serving, allow the food to rest for about 5 minutes to allow the carryover cooking to finish and the juices to set.
If you have a thin sirloin (under 1 inch thick), as an alternative, think about using the afterburner technique or, if your grill has one, using the infrared burner. In any case, the goal is to quickly sear the steak over extremely high heat before letting it rest. It will prevent your thin steaks from drying out and is the quickest method for achieving medium rare.
Ribeye 101
What what is a ribeye steak? The ribeye (or rib eye, or rib-eye) is a rich and meaty steak that gets its name from the part of the animal from which it is cut: the top rib cage near the spine. It goes by a number of names, including market steak, Spencer steak, and beauty steak, just like other steaks do. It might be offered as Scotch fillet or Entrecôte in really posh establishments. However, they are all the same steak.
Due to the mix of tenderness and robust flavor, it is one of the most popular beef steak cuts worldwide. Additionally, it is available in large 12- and 14-ounce pieces, which look fantastic on a menu. A ribeye is a fantastic option if you want tender meat. Ribeyes don’t get the same amount of workout as brisket and skirt steak, so they don’t get as tough.
Where On The Cow Does Ribeye Come From?
- Steaks called ribeye are taken from the upper portion of the cow’s rib cage, which is located between ribs 6 and 12.
- This area also contains prime rib and rib steak, which is simply a ribeye with the bone remaining in place. Do you know what a “tomahawk steak” is? It’s just a hip name for a rib steak that still has a particularly long piece of rib attached.
- The muscle of an excellent ribeye is at least 1.5 inches thick, shaped like a crooked oval, and heavily marbled with fat.
How Much Meat And Fat Does Ribeye Contain?
A ribeye has a lot of meat because it is a big cut. There is also a lot of fat, as you will discover. But that’s okay because fat contributes to flavor and juiciness. A ribeye steak typically has more fat than any other type of steak.
Nutritional Information Of Ribeye:
- Calories: 213
- Carbohydrates: 0 grams
- Fats: 11.9 grams
- Protein: 23.3 grams
- Sodium: 70 milligrams
- Cholesterol: 64 milligrams
Portion Size: How Much Ribeye Per Person?
I frequently order large portions of steak when dining out (which results in large numbers in the pricing column!).
However, in terms of practicality, a 6-ounce amount, when included in a bigger meal, is sufficient. Increase the serving size to 8–10 ounces if you intend to serve the steak as the main attraction with few sides (fries are always a fantastic choice!).
How To Prepare Ribeye For Grilling Or Smoking
You might need to prepare your ribeye a little bit before heading to the backyard. What you should know is as follows. Pick ribeye steaks that are 1.5 inches thick and well-marbled. Trimming shouldn’t be necessary, but if you notice any odd chunks of fat remaining, cut them out.
When you’re ready to grill, take the ribeyes out of the fridge and give them somewhere between 30 and 60 minutes to rest in the kitchen. As a cold steak won’t cook evenly, doing this enables the steaks to safely warm up to room temperature.
Your steak is already soft and tasty, so I wouldn’t recommend marinating it. Your steak will become disgusting mush if it spends too much time in an acid bath, which is essentially what a marinade is. Instead, generously season it with kosher salt and pepper to bring out the taste. If you’re feeling “extra,” you could even add some paprika, garlic, or other spices.
How To Cook Ribeye
Have you warmed up the grill yet? No? Now that the ribeyes are resting, it’s time to start.
On your grill, create two heat zones: one direct and medium-high, and one indirect and low. That might entail lighting just one burner or shifting all of your charcoal to one side.
- Sear the steaks first over the area of direct heat. Depending on the thickness, cook time will vary, but allow 4 to 5 minutes for each side. The ribeyes should be moved to the low-heat area after being seared.
- Using a digital thermometer is the most reliable technique to determine doneness.
- You should remove the steaks from the grill at 125F and allow them to rest for about 5 minutes because medium rare is 130F.
- The remaining portion will be provided by leftover cooking. Leave the ribeyes in the low-heat section for a few minutes, checking with your thermometer to see when they are done (we’re trying not to judge).
Ribeye steaks can also be prepared in a smoker. Get your preferred wood to 225F and select something with a medium to the heavy flavor profile. Cook until the food reaches the desired doneness and the appropriate temperature. After it is done, think about adding a brief sear on a hot burner – this is called a “reverse sear”.
Finally, frozen steaks are available for cooking! Although there are a few more steps, it’s quicker and simpler than waiting for the steak to defrost and prevents force defrosting, which can lower the quality of the final result. Learn more about grilling frozen steak in this article. However, if you’re really determined to defrost your steak, refer to our instructions for doing so.
Sirloin Vs Ribeye Detailed Comparison
It’s time for the competitor’s sirloin vs ribeye to compete now that you’ve met them! Which steak will win the competition?
Cooking Methods — Is One Easier To Cook Than The Other?
- I have to declare this one a draw in terms of preparation. Both types likely won’t require trimming, and marinating sirloin vs ribeye steaks is not necessary. However, because they are typically smaller and thinner than ribeye steaks, sirloin steaks will cook more quickly.
- The absence of fat in sirloins gives them one benefit over ribeyes. Fat does really equate to flavor and juiciness. Juiciness, however, causes drippings, and drippings on the grill can cause flare-ups. To avoid burning your ribeyes, keep a tight eye on them. You might select sirloins for this reason alone if you’re easily distracted or are new to grilling.
Is One Better For Grilling Than The Other?
These two steaks cook up well on the barbecue. They both end up tasting fantastic and are identical in size and form. Sirloin appears to be slightly more popular among grilling enthusiasts, partly because of the more alluring price and the simpler-to-cook, reduced fat content.
Sirloins are a great option for informal and family barbecues because they often come in more manageable proportions than ribeyes.
Difference In Tenderness
Ribeyes and sirloins are both tender cuts, but ribeyes come out on top in this area. On the grill, all that fat marbling renders, making the ribeyes incredibly delicate and simple to eat.
Which Is More Flavorful?
Although sirloins are not inferior in this regard, ribeyes once more take the prize. Turn up the ribeye steaks if you enjoy strong meat flavors. They don’t require sauces, marinades, or rubs since they cram a ton of flavor into every bite.
Which Is Usually Bigger?
Of course, I cannot say with certainty which is larger. However, ribeye steaks are typically bigger than sirloins, especially if you get them from a grocery store. Speak with a butcher and see what you may obtain if you want larger (or smaller) cuts than usual.
Which Is Better — Sirloin Or Ribeye?
- It’s difficult to imagine a question that is more arbitrary than this one. Each cut has some benefits over the others. How can you decide between two nice beef slices, though?
- Sirloin steaks will be declared the winner of our head-to-head competition, but feel free to disagree. Why? For grillers of any expertise level, sirloin offers a fantastic BBQ experience from fridge to fork.
- Sirloin steaks are simple to prepare, flavorful and soft, adaptable (you can slice them thin for fajitas or use them on salads, for example), well-sized, and reasonably priced for what you receive.
- You can experiment with the flavors, and you won’t feel like you spent a lot of time or money if you make something you don’t like or accidentally overcook your supper.
- Naturally, ribeyes are fantastic steaks. If you are comfortable using the grill, we strongly advise tasting them on the BBQ.
- However, sirloins are, in our opinion, the backyard champions of this coupling and need to be on every griller’s list of go-to steaks.
When Would You Pick One Over The Other
As I’ve already mentioned, sirloin steaks are incredibly flexible. They taste great sliced for fajitas or served as kabobs. Choose the sirloin steaks if you’re creating Middle Eastern or Mexican cuisine.
When it comes to beef, ribeye steaks are the ones to serve. Sometimes you just want to cook meat over a fire like a caveman! They look magnificent on the plate as well, so you’re sure to wow the boss or your pickiest relatives when you serve them a big bottle of red wine.
Three Best Recipes For Ribeye From Around The Web
While a simple s&p rub and a quick grill are plenty, here are three fascinating recipes to try for a fresh take on ribeye.
Grilled Rib-Eye Steaks With Parsley-Garlic Butter
I’ve changed my view about how underappreciated parsley is as a herb. The seasoned butter used in this dish unleashes the power of parsley. A touch of cognac and traditional garlic are also included, adding to the deliciousness. As always, salt and pepper come to the rescue when it comes to the steak itself.
Butter on top of a steak enhances its richness and helps soften a crust that slipped your attention. It’s not for everyone, to be honest; some people might find the finished result to be too rich to savor. But you have to give this one a try if you enjoy eating steak completely indulging.
Greek Grilled Ribeye Steaks
There aren’t many countries or cuisines that a recipe for steak cannot be adapted for. This recipe gives a tasty yet understated tribute to Greek cuisine. It provides a distinctive flavor experience without taking away from the ribeye steak’s outstanding, authentic flavor.
Expect a crust that is overflowing with flavor from the marinade and basting, featuring traditional Mediterranean ingredients like red wine, lemon, and olive oil. Again, to maintain the ribeye’s softness, we advise cutting down on the marinating period. This one demands your attention because of the work-to-outcome ratio.
Sizzling Spicy Rib Eye Steaks
Why allow the ribs and wings have all the fun at your dinner table if you enjoy adding heat? Your ribeyes will measure high on the Scoville scale when you use this recipe. It also demonstrates what can be done with a straightforward dry rub made from ordinary spices that the majority of us already have in our kitchens.
This rub, which combines chili powder and red pepper flakes, is unlikely to make you perspire. However, it will undoubtedly cause some tingling on your tongue, and you can easily change the amount of heat to your liking. Serving this in the summer with a cold amber or pale ale is strongly advised.
Three Best Recipes For Sirloin From Around The Web
Are sirloins ready to go? If you’re looking for something more than just a salt and pepper rub, I’ve put together a trio of delectable ways to serve your steak.
Grilled Sirloin Steak (With Red Wine Marinade)
No points for name creativity, but full marks for a tasty but straightforward marinade! You can quickly prepare this using only seven common ingredients. The recipe calls for up to an overnight marinating period for the steak, but we advise a shorter period to avoid over-softening the sirloin.
Your steaks’ flavor will be given a sophisticated depth by the rich, mildly spiced marinade, making them fit for a special event. As it isn’t overbearing, too sweet, or too spicy, it’s also practically a slam dunk for a crowd. Nothing can truly go wrong!
Grilled “Tagliata” Steak
This dish for Italian-style steak calls for serving it sliced over a bed of salad greens with dressing. (All right, OK, a salad.) It’s a terrific illustration of how adaptable sirloin truly is and how you can prepare delectable dinners with little effort, something we occasionally appreciate here.
Rub the steak with pepper, oregano, and rosemary for an easy preparation. Boom. You’ve finished. Your dinner will have a distinctly Mediterranean flavor while yet retaining the sirloin’s excellent flavor. Not only is the flavor outstanding, but you also have complete control over the quantity size, allowing you to adjust this dish to fit different diets and appetites.
Texas-Style Steak
I adore this recipe’s simplicity and promise of flavor as expansive as the Texas sky. The seven-component dry rub, which is equal parts sweet, salty, and spicy, is the crucial element. It won’t just be loaded with flavor; it will also allow the flavor of the steak to come through. We agree that a tasty steak shouldn’t be masked by copious amounts of sauce or overbearing rubs and marinades.
The recommended cooking time of 10 minutes per side is something I dislike. Although some people want their sirloin cooked to medium, we are firm believers that medium rare is the ideal. Whatever you choose to do, we’d advise grilling each side for half as long.
Related Posts:
Final Thoughts
Sirloin vs ribeye is two of the most popular cuts of beef. They’re both delicious, but they have their differences. Sirloin is a leaner cut of meat that’s less fatty than ribeye. It has a higher protein content and is lower in calories. Ribeye, on the other hand, is more marbled with fat. This means it has a higher fat content and is richer in flavor. Both cuts of meat are delicious, but if you’re looking for a healthier option, sirloin is the way to go. Sweet Basil’s Cafe hopes you now have a better understanding of the differences between sirloin vs ribeye steak, as well as when and how to prepare them. You should now be confident in making the right choice for your next steak dish!
